Liquid liner or a pencil or even eyeshadow for a 14(almost 15)yr old?

[TookiZyntag]

I think that if you're only doing the top you should use liquid eyeliner. That's just my personal preference. But with liquid liner you have to be very precise so if you are new at it I would use a pencil. If you mean you are using eyeshadow as a substitute for eyeliner I wouldn't suggest you do that because when you put it so close to your lash line, it tends to run and get all over the place. But if you use it the proper way it looks good if you put on your eyeshadow first and then put on either liquid or pencil eyeliner closer to your lash line.

If you want to put eyeliner on the bottom and not make your eyes look small there's a way to do that. Just don't put it all the way across the bottom. Start at the outer corner and work your way to almost the middle. Then take your finger and gently fade it in slightly to reach the middle. Just don't fade it out too much and let it reach the other corner of your eye.