Can anyone help me decide what phone to get?

[Jim]

Hello,
My LG Xenon stopped working (who would have guessed lol) and I need to get a new phone. I've been really looking into WP8 and I think the OS itself is incredible, so I am looking into getting a Nokia Lumia 920. The only problem is, the app selection is bad, although I heard microsoft is doing whatever they can to encourage developers to make WP8 apps (which doesn't necessarily mean it will work). I really don't want an iPhone because I simply don't really like them and I would prefer a WP8 or android. Basically, I'm having a lot of trouble choosing between the Lumia 920 and an android phone. The only Android phone I don't want really is the S3, I find the screen too big and I don't like the construction and materials used.
Do you recommend going with the Lumia 920?
If not, which android phone should I get? (Keep in mind, I'm from Canada and I would like to go on Rogers).
Thanks a lot!!