CATFISH???? Can 2 people have the same email address but with a different password?

[★Hello Kitty knows where U live♥]

Ok something weird is going on ...........I met a guy online a week ago and he seemed nice enough AND he offered to text in the beginning but I didn't want to give my real number . anyway lately he hasn't responded as much and I pretended to be a new woman and he replied quickly so when I went back as the real me I told him we don't have to meet and its fine, thanks'' but he said he was still interested . hes repeatedly said he wants to hang out and etc. soo. also he did send me pics. ive been saying that I want to voice verify and then meet in a public place but we still haven't spoken. I did some homework and I googled his email and some of it Is consistent in terms of his age and his name came up BUT his myspace profile said he was in berverly hills -it may be an old profile- and name but then I went to spokeo and a picture of a different man came up . I tried looking up IP addresses and some came up with CA and some came up with NJ which is where he claims to be from. but the spokeo search showed a different guy with a NJ ip address I think. he says hes down to meet and is down for anything yet idk. is it possible for 2 people to even have the same email