Mann vs. Curry, Round 1?

[Ottawa Mike]

In the blue corner, Michael Mann:

"Testimonies at the EPW Senate Hearing: #Science (https://twitter.com/michaelemann/status/...4207877120

In the red corner, Judy Curry:

"Since you have publicly accused my Congressional testimony of being ‘anti-science,’ I expect you to (publicly) document and rebut any statement in my testimony that is factually inaccurate or where my conclusions are not supported by the evidence that I provide." http://judithcurry.com/2014/01/18/mann-o...nsibility/

On a 10 point "must system", how do you score Round 1?

Predictions for Round 2?
____________________________________________________
@climate realist(and others): Note that I edited the links in Mann's tweet. You need to go to that tweet if you want to follow the links.