What is wrong with me?

[Cole]

I have friends, I am active, I get good grades (not "I have no life" grades, but not "I don't care about the future" grades either), I dress nice, I have a car (not that it really matters), I have a job, I grew up playing sports, I hang around "popular" people, and I am 18.

I have had 1 girlfriend in my life, she was really pretty, but we dated when I was a sophomore in high school. Now I'm a senior...

Girls don't really talk to me at school other than my friends girlfriends or in group projects.

I post a picture on Facebook or Instagram, and it either gets 2 likes or like 10-15 family/ guy friends like it.

I am 6 foot, 160 pounds. I consider myself alright looking. Read the descriptions/ scenarios above and feel free to look up "cplaskerr" on Instagram for a few pictures of me and just tell me straight up. What do you think? Males and Females. Thanks
http://instagram.com/cplaskerr