is cuddly collectibles a legit website?

[Jake]

It appears to be a legit small time operation, the site is 14 years old, which accounts in part for the funky look, it was last renewed for an additional 5 years, an indicator of someone in it for the long run. Registered to a woman in Florida. You might give the phone number a call just to get a feel for the operation. Ideally you would pay with paypal or credit card for maximum buyer protection, the checkout page where your personal data should have an https address.

You can comparison shop be searching for the product images elsewhere, the little camera icon in Google image search allows you to enter the http...address of an image you can copy off the page, it it's a manufacturer catalog image you should find the identical photo show up on several other sites. That first sponge bob image shows up on 4 other sites.