Should I even bother with him anymore? Or just move on?

[jway]

It doesn't sound like he did anything "wrong" - he likes you and he's super friendly to you but he just doesn't feel anything especially romantic for you. That's not his choice or his fault though - he feels what he feels and unfortunately what he feels is not quite what you'd like him to feel.

The problem is that there's nothing you can do about your feelings either. They're there -- you didn't ask for them to be there, they just came along all by themselves -- and pretending that you don't feel them and that he's just a friend isn't going to make them go away. Avoiding all your friends because you fear running into him isn't going to work either.

I think it's a lose-lose situation no matter what decision you make. Maybe the best thing is to just tell him what you feel? At least you won't be running away from your problems (which never really works). I don't know sorry.