Which is the best name for my character?

[Emily]

To be completely honest, the moment you said something about a scar, my mind automatically jumped to Harry Potter, so sorry for the fact that this is almost soley based around HP...
I would definitely have to agree and say Colin would be the best name. Colin reminds me of Colin Creevey from Harry Potter who had the camera and was a bit quirky and eccentric. I'd agree by saying that Jacob, Kevin, and Nathan seem a bit to "heartthrob-esque" (if that makes any sense at all...).
Your character seems quite interesting and complex--much like a normal human! I feel like often times, authors don't include enough depth to their characters and they seem to fall flat of my expectations and just be rather "ho-hum."
I assume that you're doing this for some sort of story/novel, and if you publish it on any online platform, I'd love to read it! (:
Hope this helped!