This Forum has been archived there is no more new posts or threads ... use this link to report any abusive content
==> Report abusive content in this page <==
Post Reply 
 
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Votes - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
why are some white girls so obsessed(??For lack of a better word) with being skinny?
03-09-2014, 09:20 PM
Post: #1
why are some white girls so obsessed(??For lack of a better word) with being skinny?
Hello there. I am in highschool and I was just wondering this. I asked my white friends this and they acted like they couldn't comprehend the question. Seriously. I read a lot on social sites. Things like wattpad, you know. In most of the the stories there is some girl who has some blonde, beautiful, and skinny bestfriend, while the girl has "curves" and she apparently them. Even in the well-written ones. There's a different description by the black writers who write black characters (not that those are that good to, I just can only handle one thing at a time). Typically, you write what you know. I also seen it on facebook. The captions they post on their pictures says it all. In school, all you hear is weight and hair. Some of the girls aren't even fat. It makes me wonder, what EXACTLY is their definition on skinny. I say some because I know plenty of white girls who aren't obsessed about it..
Nope. Nope. Nope. Don't give me that. Nope. Nope. Did I say nope? I guess skinny is a subjective term, so what exactly do you call skinny?
No black girl I know wants to be skinny. Nope. Nope. Nope. Same usually go for latinos. Funny thing is that you only name one, two white people? That's the point. I can't explain myself clearer because I'm on my phone at the minute. Btw, those are white models on those covers.
To make this clear, I will elaborate. What aren't you comprehending? It is culture. Typically blacks do not desire to be skinny. One look at any magazine geared towards them will probably bring this the fore-font. Tbh, I don't see many black actresses anywhere. There's a couple and I know about two out of five of them that get's called "too skinny" . Point in case, Jennifer Hudson. She lost all that weight and people were just saying stupid stuff. She wasn't even all that skinny. I thought you guys knew this. "Curves" or being "thick' is valued in the black community ( typically African american- I know some other black cultures does this, but I am trying to keep it local). Be real, Kim K. is not known for having a typical white girl body. White girls have anorexia and black girls have over-eating ( beauty is not the only sole reason). Come on, tell me don't know how they try to eat that cornbread and "soulfood" to get a n
My added details got cut off. I never said we valued being obesity. Don't put words in my mouth. Yeah, I thought I made it pretty clear, this is my view-point on how it is. Where did you get five actresses from? I know black actress(not my name) and they're all pretty skinny. I don't get your point. They're all mainstream, so they assimilated into the dominant culture. If you think I am ignorant, so be it. I never said black girls didn't obsess over their weight. I said white girls obsessed over being SKINNY. I don't know what goes on in the UK, so I can't comment.

Ads

Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
03-09-2014, 09:21 PM
Post: #2
 
I think most of them are simply obsessed with not being fat. That's an obvious issue of concern because so many are. I don't think they are obsessed with being skinny just not being fat.

Ads

Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
03-09-2014, 09:23 PM
Post: #3
 
'Skinny' is pretty much one of the Western standards of beauty - one look at the general weight of women in Hollywood, on the cover of magazines (e.g. Vogue, Marie Claire) and on the catwalk (i.e. fashion models) should make this crystal clear. Realistically it's pretty much always been that way in Hollywood and in fashion but the *really* skinny trend that's popular right now really kicked off in the 90's with the 'heroin chic' trend; which was further capitalised on by the 'size 0' trend of the '00s. There are some women like Kim Kardashian, Christina Hendricks, Beyonce and Jennifer Lopez who've deviated from that trend but realistically - none of them is really *big* at all, they're bigger by Hollywood standards. I don't think it's just a white thing - how many non-skinny black, asian or latina actresses or singers do you see hanging around Hollywood? Very few. And honestly, a lot of is just a female thing. There's a far higher degree of media scrutiny and pressure regarding female weights and sizes than men; which means most women regardless of weight feel pressure to conform to a certain size. In terms of what *I* consider skinny, a lot of it depends on height - a US size 10 looks different on someone at 5ft1 than 5ft 8. But in general terms, US sizes 0-2/4 are what I consider skinny and US size 4-6 would be what I consider to be slim.

Hope this helps

(:
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
03-09-2014, 09:37 PM
Post: #4
 
Your friends couldn't comprehend your question just like I can't quite comprehend your additional details.

But the reason why some white girls obsess about being skinny is the same as other races do... Celebrities, boys and body image issues. It's not exclusive to white girls. Maybe you don't know any black girls who obsess about their weight but in the wider world the are plenty who do.

Edit: I can't comprehend all your blabbering. You need to be more concise with YOUR opinions. I'm in the UK but like I already said regardless of race, most girls obsess about their weight/ image; no race is immune to that.

I know in the US a lot of black people have lower incomes. And it is known that poorer people (in developed countries) make bad diet choices, whether they're black, white or purple. It's just as ignorant for you to generalise your own race as it would be for anyone else.

And if you only know 5 black actresses and think we value obesity then sadly I think you are ignorant.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Forum Jump:


User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)