Double crush?

[Cassy]

I kinda like to guys..... One of them I've never met but I've seen his photos and stalked him on Facebook and he seems like a cool guy and he is my best friends friend and she honestly says really good things about him and how we should start dating and my bff wouldn't lie to me so everything that she has told me about him is true. Also that kid doesn't go to my school. Then there is another guy who is in my school but a different class, he's nice and stuff but i don't like him that much and everyone thinks he has a crush on me but he has never admitted it.. I'm so confused on who i like better. For the first kid he said i was kinda cute.

[Mary]

First

[Makayla]

“if you love two people at the same time, choose the second. Because if you really loved the first one, you wouldn't have fallen for the second.” -Jonny Depp

[Erin]

how old are you? if your still in high school (which i'm thinking you must be) you should just let it be and see who comes to you. you may really like the first guy who you've stalked on facebook and your friend tells you great things about, but whose to say he will like you back. you have better chances of giving the second guy a chance!
i mean, ultimately its your choice, but i'd go with the second guy, whom you've heard has a crush on you. only seems natural to try to be with someone who likes you back other than someone who may not even know you exist.