Is blog commenting effective for SEO and web traffic or seen as spam? (after google panda and penguin update)?

[Amendoa]

plus can we post a comment on any niche site or just within the niche field?
and what is recommended in the name texfield? (keyword or brand name)?

[Caren]

i don't understand your question fully, because im really dumb.
but i do know that you cannot advertise here. not even blog site advertising

[Khuzaima]

Its very simple, always comment relative to the given content.
Example: If the content is about curtain fabrics and you comment about your business besides curtain fabrics i.e. sports shoes then this would count in spam.

Blog commenting is a major part of SEO but you must not make a habbit to do SEO only by help of blog commenting. Do it 2-3 times a week.

As far is google panda & penguin are concerned, its just saying to bring your site to a competitive keyword in search engine, your site must contain that keyword in the unique content uploaded on your site/blog. Making too much blog commenting will make the web-address spam if its on irrelevant posts.

[SynapseIndia]

Hello,

First of all I want to inform you that whatever we are doing on web is natural. If we will think about our keyword and brand then this will be the spam work. This is sure when we are working on web then there will be some identity for us that will be our brand.

So still blog commenting is helpful but you have to natural in content and link. You have to avoid the promotional activity. Sure you will get the positive response.