Should I stay in this relationship?

[Reese]

if you have to ask, then no.
Text me and we'll talk..
8569167628
USA

[James]

Thats messed up. Don't stay in it.

[Pieman]

Should you? No, you should end it. And if he cares more about her, and cares nothing about your feelings, it's likely already over.

[Scooter]

Dump him he has no right to treat u like shit, I think girls should be treated with respect and kindness, he obviously doesn't give a shit so leave him, he's just dead weight girl hope I helped

[Tolly]

no you shouldnt but u should go out with me

[Cara]

listen to your heart and go with what you feel

[Rebecca Boylan]

If he is yelling at you, saying this is your fault, it means he's just trying to cover up something that he's doing. I would really sit down and talk to him, and sort things out!

[Sunshyne]

End it. He should care more about your feelings than this "poor girls" feelings. Period. Since he obviously doesn't, you have your answer. Do you want to be with somebody who cares about another females feelings more than yours? Sounds like he's playing both of you.

[Britt]

Personally, if I were in this situation, I would, at some point confront him again, but this time I would ask him to just hear you out, and not interrupt you. If he still yells at you, I would just remove yourself from the situation and end the relationship. Although you probably would still be questioning yourself if that happens, There is absolutely no reason for you to stay in a relationship with someone who doesn't care about you or your feelings

[Pr]

You may not like my answer but you are better off out of the relationship. If the "girlfriend" has been honest they have been deceiving you for 2.5 years. In my opinion there was something amiss that he clearly maintained contact with this girl - I think that he has been two-timing both of you. The fact that he took her side against yours proves where his interests lie. Dump him now - and if he has been cheating on both of you then he will end up with nothing - or with her and I would say she is welcome to him. Move on and be happy